刘雄峰;邵亦文;孙瑶;

• 1:深圳大学建筑与城市规划学院
• 2:暨南大学深圳旅游学院

摘要(Abstract)：

城市道路是城市交通基础设施的主要组成部分。道路网络的整体韧性水平对于不确定扰动影响下维持城市基本运转、实现城市整体韧性目标而言,具有十分重要的意义。本文通过分析基于Web of Science核心数据库检索与重要引文补充相结合形成的文献数据集,全面回顾了城市道路网络韧性的相关研究,重点讨论了道路网络韧性的定义内涵、衡量指标和常用研究方法,并提出了若干具有一定潜力的研究角度。

关键词(KeyWords)： 城市道路网络;韧性;定义内涵;衡量指标;研究方法

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金委员会青年科学基金项目(项目批准号:51908362);; 深圳市孔雀计划科研启动基金(项目批准号:827000436)

作者(Authors): 刘雄峰;邵亦文;孙瑶;

DOI: 10.19974/j.cnki.CN21-1508/TU.2022.12.0265

参考文献(References)：

• [1]FATURECHI R,MILLER-HOOKS E.Measuring the Performance of Transportation InfrastructureSystems in Disasters:A Comprehensive Review[J].Journal of Infrastructure Systems,2014,21(1):4014025.
• [2]ZHOU Y,WANG J,YANG H.Resilience of Transportation Systems:Concepts and Comprehensive Review[J].IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems,2019,20(12):4262-4276.
• [3]SERDAR M Z,KO?M,AL-GHAMDI S G.Urban Transportation Networks Resilience:Indicators,Disturbances,and Assessment Methods[J].Sustainable Cities and Society,2021,76:103452.
• [4]HELDEROP E,GRUBESIC T H.Streets,storm surge,and the frailty of urban transport systems:A grid-based Approach for identifying informal street network connections to facilitate mobility[J].Transportation Research Part D:Transport and Environment,2019,77:337-351.
• [5]汶川特大地震四川抗震救灾志编纂委员会.汶川特大地震四川抗震救灾志·总述大事记[M].成都:四川人民出版社,2017.
• [6]RACHAEL DOTTLE R K A E.Hurricane Harvey's impact and how it compares to other storms.[EB/OL].[2022.1.22].https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/hurricane-harveys-impact-and-how-itcompares-to-other-storms/.
• [7]国务院灾害调查组.河南郑州“7·20”特大暴雨灾害调查报告[R].2022.
• [8]MARSHALL S.Street&pattern[M].New York:spon press,2005.
• [9]苑思楠.城市街道网络空间形态定量分析[D].天津:天津大学,2012.
• [10]ALEXANDER C.A City is not a Tree[J].Archit Forum,1963.
• [11]HOLLING C S.Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems[J].Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,1973.
• [12]邵亦文,徐江.城市韧性:基于国际文献综述的概念解析[J].国际城市规划,2015,30(02):48-54.
• [13]JHA A,MINER T W,STANTON-GEDDES Z.Building Urban Resilience:Principles,Tools,and Practice[M].The World Bank Group,2013.
• [14]MURRAY-TUITE P M.A comparison of transportation network resilience under simulated system optimum and user equilibrium conditions[J].Winter simulation,2006:1398-1405.
• [15]SERULLE N U,HEASLIP K,BRADY B,et al.Resiliency of Transportation Network of Santo Domingo,Dominican Republic Case Study[J].Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2011(2234):22-30.
• [16]CALVERT S C,SNELDER M.A methodology for road traffic resilience analysis and review of related concepts[J].Transportmetrica A Transport Science,2015,14(1-2):130-154.
• [17]QIANG Y,XU J.Empirical assessment of road network resilience in natural hazards using crowdsourced traffic data[J].International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2019,34(12):1-17.
• [18]BALAL E,VALDEZ G,MIRAMONTES J,et al.Comparative evaluation of measures for urban highway network resilience due to traffic incidents[J].International Journal of Transportation Science and Technology,2019,8(3):304-317.
• [19]GU Y,FU X,LIU Z,et al.Performance of transportation network under perturbations:Reliability,vulnerability,and resilience[J].Transportation Research Part E,2019,133(C):101809.
• [20]IIDA Y,WAKABAYASHI H.AN EFFICIENT CALCULATION METHOD TO OBTAIN UPPER AND LOWER BOUNDS OF TERMINAL RELIABILITY OF ROAD NETWORKS USING BOOLEAN ALGEBRA[J].Doboku Gakkai Ronbunshu,1988,1988(395):75-84.
• [21]SOLTANI-SOBH A,HEASLIP K,KHOURY J E.Estimation of road network reliability on resiliency:An uncertain based model[J].International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction,2015,14:536-544.
• [22]NICHOLSON A J.Road Network Unreliability:Impact Assessment and Mitigation[J].International Journal of Critical Infrastructures,2007,3(3/4):346-375.
• [23]BERDICA K.An introduction to road vulnerability:what has been done,is done and should be done[J].Transport Policy,2002,9(2):117-127.
• [24]HUSDAL J.Reliability and vulnerability versus costs and benefits:INSTR 2004[C],2004.
• [25]WIELAND A,WALLENBURG C M.Dealing with supply chain risks:Linking risk managementpractices and strategies to performance[J].International Journal of Physical Distribution&Logistics Management,2012,42(10):887-905.
• [26]SNELDER M,ZUYLEN H,IMMERS L H.A framework for robustness analysis of road networks for short term variations in supply[J].Transportation Research Part A Policy and Practice,2012,46(5):828-842.
• [27]HOLMGREN A J.A Framework for Vulnerability Assessment of Electric Power Systems[M].Critical Infrastructure,2007.
• [28]SHARIFI A.Resilient urban forms:A review of literature on streets and street networks[J].Building and Environment,2019,147:171-187.
• [29]SUN W,BOCCHINI P,DAVISON B D.Resilience metrics and measurement methods for transportation infrastructure:the state of the art[J].Sustainable&Resilient Infrastructure,2020,5(3):168-199.
• [30]ZHANG X,MILLER-HOOKS E,DENNY K.Assessing the role of network topology in transportation network resilience[J].Journal of Transport Geography,2015,46(jun):35-45.
• [31]LIN J,BAN Y.Complex Network Topology of Transportation Systems[J].Transport Reviews,2013,33(6):27-33.
• [32]CRUCITTI P,LATORA V,PORTA S.Centrality in networks of urban streets[J].Chaos,2006,16(1):15113.
• [33]ANOP M.Using Graph Model to Analyze the Topological Vulnerability of Transport Infrastructure[J].DOOR,2016:358-366.
• [34]WANG J.Resilience of Self-Organised and TopDown Planned Cities-A Case Study on London and Beijing Street Networks[J].PLoS ONE,2015,10(12):e141736.
• [35]DIESTEL R,KRAL D,SEYMOUR P.Graph Theory[J].Oberwolfach Reports,2016,13(1):51-86.
• [36]AYDIN N Y,DUZGUN H S,WENZEL F,et al.Integration of stress testing with graph theory to assess the resilience of urban road networks under seismic hazards[J].Natural Hazards,2018,91(1):1-32.
• [37]OSEI-ASAMOAH A,LOWNES N E.Complex Network Method of Evaluating Resilience in Surface Transportation Networks[J].Transportation Research Record:Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2014,2467(1):120-128.
• [38]IP W H,WANG D.Resilience and Friability of Transportation Networks:Evaluation,Analysis and Optimization[J].IEEE Systems Journal,2011,5(2):189-198.
• [39]MATTSSON L G,JENELIUS E.Vulnerability and resilience of transport systems-A discussion of recent research[J].Transportation Research Part A,2015,81(NOV.):16-34.
• [40]VISHNU N,KAMESHWAR S,PADGETT J E.Road transportation network hazard sustainability and resilience:correlations and comparisons[J].Structure and Infrastructure Engineering,2021:1-21.
• [41]DONOVAN B,WORK D B.Empirically quantifying city-scale transportation system resilience to extreme events[J].Transportation Research Part C:Emerging Technologies,2017,79(JUN.):333-346.
• [42]OMER M,MOSTASHARI A,NILCHIANI R.Assessing resilience in a regional road-based transportation network[J].Int.J.of Industrial and Systems Engineering,2013,13:389-408.
• [43]IOANNIS,KILANITIS,ANASTASIOS,et al.Impact of earthquake-induced bridge damage and time evolving traffic demand on the road network resilience[J].Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering(English Edition),2019,v.6;No.31(01):41-54.
• [44]AHMED S,DEY K,FRIES R.Evaluation of Transportation System Resilience in the Presence of Connected and Automated Vehicles[J].Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2019,2673(7):862974490.
• [45]MARTIN B,ORTEGA E,CUEVAS-WIZNER R,et al.Assessing road network resilience:An accessibility comparative analysis[J].Transportation Research Part D Transport and Environment,2021,95(4):102851.
• [46]CHANG STEPHANIE E.Transportation planning for disasters:an accessibility Approach.[J].Environment&Planning A,2003,35(6):1051-1072.
• [47]BRUNEAU M,CHANG S E,EGUCHI R T,et al.A Framework to Quantitatively Assess and Enhancethe Seismic Resilience of Communities[J].Earthquake Spectra,2003,19(4):733-752.
• [48]WANG H W,PENG Z R,WANG D,et al.Evaluation and prediction of transportation resilience under extreme weather events:A diffusion graph convolutional Approach[J].Transportation Research Part C Emerging Technologies,2020,115:102619.
• [49]TANG J Q,HEINIMANN H R.A resilience-oriented Approach for quantitatively assessing recurrent spatial-temporal congestion on urban roads[J].PLOS ONE,2018,13(1).
• [50]AHMED S,DEY K.Resilience modeling concepts in transportation systems a comprehensive review based on mode,and modeling techniques[J].Journal of Infrastructure Preservation and Resilience,2020,1(1):8.
• [51]PAULINE G,ANGELO F,NOUR-EDDIN E F.Road network resilience:how to identify critical links subject to day-to-day disruptions?[J].Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2018,2672(1):54-65.
• [52]FRECKLETON D,HEASLIP K,LOUISELL W,et al.Evaluation of Resiliency of Transportation Networks After Disasters[J].TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD,2012(2284):109-116.
• [53]GONALVES L A P J,RIBEIRO P J G.Resilience of urban transportation systems.Concept,characteristics,and methods[J].Journal of Transport Geography,2020:102727.
• [54]REGGIANI A,NIJKAMP P,LANZI D.Transport resilience and vulnerability:The role of connectivity[J].Transportation Research Part A,2015,81:4-15.
• [55]ROOSTA M,JAVADPOOR M,EBADI M.A study on street network resilience in urban areas by urban network analysis:comparative study of old,new and middle fabrics in shiraz[J].International Journal of Urban Sciences,2021(4):1-23.
• [56]KALPANA L D C H,JAYASINGHE A B,ABENAYAKE C C,et al.NETWORK CENTRALITY ASSESSMENT(NCA):ASSESSING THE TRANSPORT NETWORK RESILIENCE TO URBAN FLOODING[J].2021:99-114.
• [57]SANTOS J R,SAFITRI N D,SAFIRA M,et al.Road network vulnerability and city-level characteristics:A nationwide comparative analysis of Japanese cities[J].Environment and Planning B,2021,48(5):1091-1107.
• [58]CASCETTA E.Transportation systems analysis.Models and Applications.2nd ed[M].2009.
• [59]NI X,OSARAGI T,HUANG H,et al.ResilienceOriented Performance Assessment Method for Road-Traffic System:A Case Study in Beijing,China[J].KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering,2021,25(10):3977-3994.
• [60]ILBEIGI M.Statistical process control for analyzing resilience of transportation networks[J].International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction,2019,33:155-161.
• [61]MOJTAHEDI M,NEWTON S,MEDING J V.Predicting the resilience of transport infrastructure to a natural disaster using Cox's proportional hazards regression model[J].Natural Hazards,2017,85(2):1119-1133.
• [62]HROMKOVIC J.Algorithmics for Hard Problems:Introduction to Combinatorial Optimization,Randomization,Approximation,and Heuristics[M].Algorithmics for Hard Problems:Introduction to Combinatorial Optimization,Randomization,Approximation,and Heuristics,2010.
• [63]IP W H,WANG D.Resilience Evaluation Approach of Transportation Networks:International Joint Conference on Computational Sciences&Optimization[C],2009.
• [64]FATURECHI R,MILLER-HOOKS E.Travel time resilience of roadway networks under disaster[J].Transportation Research Part B:Methodological,2014,70(dec.):47-64.
• [65]LIAO T,TA-YIN H,YI-NO K.A resilience optimization model for transportation networks under disasters[J].Natural Hazards,2018,93(1):469-489.
• [66]KAVIANI A,THOMPSON R G,RAJABIFARD A.Improving regional road network resilience by optimised traffic guidance[J].Transportmetrica A Transport Science,2017,13(9):794-828.
• [67]YE Q,UKKUSURI S V.Resilience as an Objective in the Optimal Reconstruction Sequence for Transportation Networks[J].Journal ofTransportation Safety&Security,2015,7(1):91-105.
• [68]TANG J,HEINIMANN H,HAN K,et al.Evaluating resilience in urban transportation systems for sustainability:A systems-based Bayesian network model[J].Transportation Research Part C Emerging Technologies,2020,121:102840.
• [69]LAM J C,ADEY B T.Functional Loss Assessment and Restoration Analysis to Quantify Indirect Consequences of Hazards[J].ASCE-ASME Journal of Risk and Uncertainty in Engineering Systems,Part A:Civil Engineering,2016,2(4):4016008.
• [70]EB A,GV B,JM A,et al.Comparative evaluation of measures for urban highway network resilience due to traffic incidents[J].International Journal of Transportation Science and Technology,2019,8(3):304-317.
• [71]NOGAL M,CONNOR A O,MARTINEZ-PASTOR B,et al.Novel Probabilistic Resilience Assessment Framework of Transportation Networks against Extreme Weather Events[J].ASCE-ASME Journal of Risk and Uncertainty in Engineering Systems,Part A:Civil Engineering,2017,3(3):4017003.
• [72]LI C,FANG Q,DING L,et al.Time-dependent resilience analysis of a road network in an extreme environment[J].Transportation Research Part D Transport and Environment,2020,85(10):102395.
• [73]DUY P N,CHAPMAN L,TIGHT M.Resilient transport systems to reduce urban vulnerability to floods in emerging-coastal cities:A case study of Ho Chi Minh City,Vietnam[J].Travel Behaviour and Society,2019,15:28-43.
• [74]SERDAR M Z,AL-GHAMDI S G.Resiliency Assessment of Road Networks during Mega Sport Events:The Case of FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022[J].Sustainability,2021,13(22):12367.
• [75]LHOMME S,SERRE D,DIAB Y,et al.Analyzing resilience of urban networks:a preliminary step towards more flood resilient cities[J].Natural hazards and earth system sciences,2013,13(2):221-230.
• 检索时,分别将“road network"与resilien*、resilien*与"road system""transportation network"与resilience等关键词通过检索运算符and串联,形成不同检索字段(如“road network"and resilien*),再通过检索运算符or将各字段并列后进行检索(关键词前后加上双引号则会视为短语,如“road network";使用星号可替代其后的若干字母,如resilien*可检索到resilience和resilient)。